Italy's data protection authority (Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, GPDP) has fined Meta €805 million over the Facebook app's access to users' photos and videos on Android, as reported by Habr. The regulator found that the company never properly explained to roughly 20 million smartphone owners that it had this access. By Italian standards, the sum is a record — one of the largest fines the country has ever imposed on a tech company.
The mechanics are simple, and that's what makes it unpleasant. The app offers photos and videos from your gallery as ideas for posts. Facebook asks for gallery permission once — for the entire app — and never mentions that the same access also powers its recommendations. Now there's a deadline: 60 days to switch the feature off by default and obtain users' separate consent. The company's position: "This is a simple feature that helps people share photos and videos to Facebook. It requires device permissions to work, and those permissions can be changed at any time in settings." A Meta spokesperson said the company will appeal the decision.
Some context from the source: a month ago, New Mexico ordered Meta to pay $25 billion after the company was found liable for misleading consumers about privacy. And the mandatory Habr footnote: Meta has been designated an extremist organization in Russia, where Facebook and Instagram are banned.
The number is impressive, but the framing of the complaint is what's really interesting. The regulator isn't going after the access itself — the access existed, the user granted permission — but the fact that people were never told about the second purpose. Our read: this is a direct hit on the "one permission covers everything" pattern that half of all mobile apps build their onboarding on. In the GPDP's view, consent given for one task and spent on another simply isn't consent.
What this changes for users. Until now, the question "why does Facebook need my gallery?" got answered in your head in two seconds: to post stuff. Now people have a legitimate reason to ask the same thing of any app that requests photos, microphone, and contacts in a single prompt. That, we think, is the real practical impact of this story — not the euros in the headline.
Who wins and who loses. Regulators and lawyers win — they've got a fresh benchmark for the price of "implied consent." Meta, if you count in dollars, got off with a reporting headache: €805 million against $25 billion in New Mexico is less than it sounds. The losers, our hypothesis, are small developers, who'll have to rewrite their consent screens without a legal department on staff. There's nothing in the source to confirm or refute that hypothesis.
The source doesn't link to the GPDP's actual decision, so we don't know how the 20 million figure was calculated or over what period. It doesn't say how many Italian users the feature actually affected, or exactly when Meta must report back on disabling it by default. No timeline for the appeal, either. The source's weak spot is that it's a retelling: it conveys the regulator's position and Meta's quote, but not the text of the ruling. Check the Garante's website, not the summaries.
Forecast: within the quarter, Meta will switch "ideas for posts" off by default for Italian accounts at least, without waiting for the appeal: the risk of a repeat fine costs more than a few unshown posts. You'll be able to verify this via a Facebook app update in the Italian region.
Source: Habr
Source: habr.com · post in Telegram